7th August 2024 Planning Committee – Additional Representations

 

 

 

Page

Site Address

Application No.

Comment

 

Item A, p23

Royal Pavilion Gardens

Pavilion Buildings

BH2023/02835

Up-date plans list

Updated Condition 1

amended plan for clarification of tree removal

 

Plan Type

Reference

Version

Date Received

Report/Statement

Arboricultural Impact Assessment 

J21177_Arb_B Rev. B

1st August 2024

 

Additional plan for clarification of tree removal

Plan Type

Reference

Version

Date Received

Proposed Drawing

Tree Works Summary

 

1st August 2024

 

 

 

Item B, p59

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Item B, p63

Royal Pavilion Gardens

Pavilion Buildings

BH2023/02836

Up-date plans list

Updated Informative

amended plan for clarification of tree removal

 

Plan Type

Reference

Version

Date Received

Report/Statement

Arboricultural Impact Assessment 

J21177_Arb_B Rev. B

1st August 2024

 

Additional plan for clarification of tree removal

Plan Type

Reference

Version

Date Received

Proposed Drawing

Tree Works Summary

 

1st August 2024

 

 

Following readvertisement due to amendments, further 2 (two) objections have been received from The Brighton Society and Living Streets raising the following:

-       Welcome improvements to the gardens/omission of gates but uphold objection to the proposed railings surrounding the site,

-       Revisions to boundaries and entrances is confusing as it states that the gates will be omitted but no justification for installing the proposed high railings, still implies not public gardens and forms visual and psychological barrier between the community and the gardens,

-       Cost of railings and the maintenance,

-       24-hour access needs to be ensured via covenants,

-       internal railing design, and

-       internal railings should only be used where protection is necessary t separate pathways from flowerbeds and shrubberies, elsewhere they would be atrip hazard.

 

Following readvertisement due to amendments, further 1 (one) comment has been received noting the following:

-       support positive benefit and enhance the gardens, their preservation and that of the Dome itself in all respects, and

-       object to decision to keep the gardens open at night – cannot see any justification for them being kept open, police report has been ignored, gardens impacted at night by anti-social behaviour. 

 

Officer note: no additional issues raised that have not already been addressed in the Officer Report.

 

 

Item C, p99

Windlesham House 123 Windlesham Close Portslade BN41 2AB

 

 

BH2023/02790

Correction to the Officer Report paragraph 9.25:

“Four habitable spaces (serving three four separate flats) are identified as being the

worst affected: …”

Item D, p116

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

P115

Sussex County Cricket Ground

BH2024/00904

Additional consultee response:

County Ecology: No objection subject to condition

The design and access statement references planting but no details have been provided in terms of number of plants/species etc. This should be secured by condition.

 

Condition 19 of outline application BH2023/02914 requires details of any external lighting scheme, this should still apply.

 

One (1) additional letter of support has been received raising the following:

-The new stands will be an improvement as the temporary stands are an eyesore and uncomfortable.

-The new stands will improve accessibility

-The stands will ensure growth of the cricket club

-The stands will not increase capacity beyond the current license

 

 

Item F, p150

120 Holland Road

Hove

BN3 1JR

BH2024/01297

 

Error in report at 9.17 incorrectly references the host property at 120 Holland Road and should instead refer to the northern neighbour at 122 Holland Road.

“It is acknowledged that there would be a degree of loss of direct sunlight and some degree of overshadowing during the winter months particularly of the neighbouring glazed roof at 120 Holland Road 122 Holland Road”

Item G, p159

45 Norfolk Road, Brighton

BH2023/03393

Updated Condition 1 – amended set of plans following site visit:

 

1.         The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the approved drawings listed below.

Reason: For the avoidance of doubt and in the interests of proper planning.

 

Plan Type

Reference

Version

Date Received

Location Plan

SU001  

-

8 February 2024

Existing Drawing

EX003

-

9 April 2024

Proposed Drawing

PL004  

E

23 July 2024

Proposed Drawing

PL005  

C

5 April 2024

Proposed Drawing

PL006  

E

14 May 2024

Proposed Drawing

PL007  

B

23 July 2024

Proposed Drawing

PL008  

D

23 July 2024

Proposed Drawing

PL009  

A

23 July 2024

Block Plan

PL050  

-

5 April 2024

Detail

Samsung WindFree 1-Way Cassette  

-

8 February 2024

 

 

 

 

Item H, p175

7 Saxon Close

Saltdean

Brighton

BN2 8GA

BH2024/00692

Deletion of duplicated condition

Condition 19 to be deleted as duplicates condition 9, but with updated plans which should be referred to.

 

Condition 9 should now read:

“The dwelling hereby approved shall be implemented in strict accordance with the internal layouts detailed on the proposed floorplans TA1398/11 C and 175TA1398/12 C received on 19th July 2023 TA1398/11 D, TA1398/12 D and TA1398/20 received on 15th March 2024. The internal layouts shall be retained as first implemented thereafter.

Reason: To ensure an acceptable standard of accommodation for future occupiers is provided and maintained thereafter and to comply with policy DM1 of the Brighton and Hove City Plan Part Two.”

 

 

Item J, p205

47 Eastbrook Road

Portslade

BN41 1LN

BH2024/00872

Additional comment received:

 

A further comment has been received objecting to the proposal for the following reasons:

-       Overdevelopment

-       Loss of property value

-       Additional traffic

-       If HMO then this will be problematic

 

Officer response: No additional issues raised that have not already been addressed in the Officer Report. HMO use is not sought.

 

 

Item J, p208

47 Eastbrook Road

Portslade

BN41 1LN

BH2024/00872

Correction to the Officer Report paragraph 9.14:

 

“9.14. One of the representations has raised concerns about trees in the garden but no trees would be affected by the scheme. Concern was also raised over the presence of slow worms but given the small scale of the scheme and permitted development fall-back, it is not considered proportionate to seek further surveys. The applicant is still required to comply with the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 (as amended) where slow worms are protected under Schedule 5.”

 

 

Item O, p267

70A Clarendon Villas

Hove

BN3 3RA

BH2024/00941

Updated Condition 1 – amended set of approved plans following site visit:

 

1.         The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the approved drawings listed below.

Reason: For the avoidance of doubt and in the interests of proper planning.

 

Plan Type

Reference

Version

Date Received

Proposed Drawing

PL-10

-

10 May 2024

Detail

PROPOSED WINDOWS & DOORS

-

16 April 2024